Seize the RARE opportunity to become the third owner of this exceptional hilltop property, offering a difficult to find blend of privacy and proximity to downtown amenities and JMU campus. Positioned at the end of Old Town's only cul-de-sac, 424 Monticello Ave offers a rare sanctuary of tranquility amidst our bustling town. Custom built in 1975, this custom brick home seamlessly blends classic architecture with modern amenities, including an attached two-car garage, a rarity in Old Town. The main level boasts an inviting foyer, formal living and dining rooms, and a spectacular family room adorned with a wood burning fireplace and charming built-ins. The chef's kitchen is a dream, featuring a massive island, two ovens, two dishwashers, a gas range, commercial fridge, and even a lovely wet bar. Sunlight streams through the south facing sunroom, which overlooks the lush, private, professionally landscaped/hardscaped backyard oasis and JMU campus beyond. Upstairs, you'll find a luxurious primary suite, two spacious bedrooms, and an adorable guest bath. The lower level offers ample additional space for fun, with a sprawling rec room, fourth bedroom, an updated full bath, and an unfinished workshop. Don't let this opportunity slip away!